// case #0006 · filed 2026-08-11 · decided 2026-08-11

VERDICT OVERTURNED

Sierra · RECOVERS — yes → uncertain

The Sierra dossier → Download the ruling card Every case →

The ruling

The evidence won. The dataset changed.

The evidence behind the YES was supervisors reviewing responses in flight and stepping agents back on track — oversight correcting the agent, not the agent working out a different attempt. No tool-call retry is documented either way, so rule 04 can be neither met nor refused on this record. This is the only ruling of the six that moved a score down.

PRODUCT: Sierra
CRITERION: RECOVERS
RESULT: yes → uncertain
SCORE: 5/5 AGENT → 4/5 AGENT
FILED BY: editorial internal audit
VENDOR AFFILIATION: none — filed by the editors against their own verdict
EVIDENCE: sierra.ai
REVISION: sierra@2026-08-11

Sierra stands at 4/5 AGENT today. Think this ruling is wrong too? File against it — cases can be reopened by new evidence.