// bring a trace and a verdict changes

The court

Every challenge to a verdict, the evidence behind it, and the ruling — including the ones where we were wrong. A verdict overturned by evidence is the best thing that happens here.

7cases
6overturned
1upheld
0open
01

Cases

1 shown · every ID is permanent
  1. VERDICT UPHELD
    LangGraph · RECOVERS filed by editorial internal audit · 2026-08-11 · decided 2026-08-11

    The claim was that RetryPolicy and error handlers constitute recovery. Rule 04 excludes repeating the identical call, and RetryPolicy re-runs the identical node attempt; the error handler is a developer-written hook, a primitive the framework provides rather than the framework devising an alternative. Verdict upheld.

    the evidence → · case #0001 →

Community votes never move a verdict on their own. Evidence does, and the reasoning that moved it is printed above in full.

02

File a challenge

evidence, not opinion

Name the product and the criterion, and link a trace, a doc page, or a recorded run that shows the behaviour. Vendors are welcome, and a vendor's own filing is labelled as such on the case. Sponsorship does not move a verdict and does not move a case up the queue.